How snowflakes grow
A snowflake is not frozen rain. It grows, molecule by molecule, out of water vapor in a cold cloud.
Snow crystal or snowflake?
Physicists are careful with these words. A snow crystal is a single crystal of ice, with its water molecules lined up in a precise hexagonal pattern. A snowflake is a looser word: it can mean one snow crystal, or a fluffy clump of hundreds or even thousands of crystals that bumped into each other and stuck together as they fell. Caltech physicist Kenneth Libbrecht puts it simply: calling a snow crystal a snowflake is fine, like calling a tulip a flower.
Snow crystals are not frozen raindrops either. Frozen raindrops are sleet. A snow crystal forms when water vapor turns directly into ice without first becoming liquid water.
It starts with a seed
Cloud droplets can stay liquid well below freezing. According to the Met Office, the United Kingdom's weather service, a droplet only freezes on its own at about -35 C (-31 F) or colder. In warmer clouds it needs something to freeze onto, such as a speck of dust or pollen.
Once that tiny ice crystal exists, water vapor from the surrounding air keeps freezing onto it, and it grows as it falls. NOAA, the United States weather and oceans agency, describes the six arms of a snowflake as being built this way, from water vapor freezing onto the first crystal.
Why six?
The six-fold shape comes from inside the ice. Water molecules in an ice crystal join together in a hexagonal arrangement, and the crystal's outside reflects that inner order.
- A brand-new snow crystal is a simple hexagonal prism, with two flat ends and six sides. Slow growth keeps it like this, and these simple crystals are usually small.
- Depending on conditions, the prism can grow into a flat plate or a long column, or anything in between.
- As a plate grows larger, branches sprout from its six corners, and side branches can sprout from those. That is how the familiar star shape appears.
No blueprint guides this. Libbrecht describes three processes at work: faceting, which makes flat, orderly faces; branching, which makes complex, chaotic structures; and sharpening, which pushes growth toward thin plates, mostly near -15 C (5 F).
How the arms grow alike
If the six arms grow separately, why do they look so similar? Because they travel together. As a crystal tumbles through a cloud, the temperature and humidity around it keep changing, and each change makes the arms grow a little differently. All six arms feel the same changes at the same moment, so they change in step.
Nothing else links them. Libbrecht compares it to a rainy morning: you and your neighbors all carry umbrellas without talking to each other, because you all looked out at the same weather.
One more surprise: most snow crystals are not very symmetrical at all. Irregular crystals are by far the most common kind. The near-perfect stars in photographs are real, but they are the rare beauties that photographers go looking for.
How big can they get?
- The smallest snow crystals, called diamond dust, can be no wider than a human hair. They glitter in sunlight in bitterly cold weather.
- The largest single snow crystals, fernlike stellar dendrites, can be up to about 5 millimeters (0.2 inches) across.
- Snowflakes made of many crystals stuck together are bigger. The National Snow and Ice Data Center says most are less than 1.3 centimeters (0.5 inches) across, but under the right conditions -- usually near freezing, with light winds -- irregular flakes can approach 5 centimeters (2 inches). Nobody measures snowflake size routinely, so the true maximum is not known.
Why snow looks white
Each snow crystal is clear ice. Snow looks white because all those tiny crystal faces scatter and reflect light of every color about equally, so what comes back to your eyes is white light.
Deep snow can look blue. Light that travels a long way through snow -- say a meter (about 3 feet) or more -- loses a little more red than blue on the way, so if you poke a deep hole in snow and look in, you may see a bluish glow.
No two alike?
The saying goes back to the Vermont farmer Wilson Bentley, who photographed more than 5,000 snow crystals and never found two the same. Is it true? Libbrecht's answer is that it depends on what you mean.
- Simple crystals can look alike. Plain hexagonal prisms often look nearly identical under a microscope.
- Complex crystals almost certainly never match. A complex snow crystal may have a hundred separate features you can pick out. Libbrecht compares this to arranging 100 books on a shelf: there are so many possible orders that the number has 158 digits. Even with roughly a million billion billion snow crystals forming each year, he concludes it is unlikely any two complex ones in Earth's history have looked exactly alike.
- Lab twins come close. Libbrecht has grown "identical-twin" snowflakes side by side in his laboratory. Because the pair grew under the same changing conditions, they came out nearly the same shape -- clearly similar, but not precisely identical.
What is still a mystery
Scientists can explain a lot about branching. What they still cannot fully explain is why ice grows as thin plates at some temperatures and slender columns at others. The answer lies in how water molecules behave at the surface of ice, and as Libbrecht puts it, surface physics is complicated. There remains, in his words, "a bit of mystery" in every snowflake.